top of page

What the Homicide Count Leaves Out

Nov 7
2 min read

Prevention lesson from Malcolm Gladwell’s The American Way of Killing


A Chicago elementary school student asked emergency physician Abdullah Pratt for a new trauma kit. She’d used the first one after someone was shot outside her home. Pratt had given her that kit and taught her what to do in those first few minutes. Malcolm Gladwell tells the story early in The American Way of Killing. She was ready before the emergency, and being ready mattered.

Gladwell covers a lot of ground, but I kept coming back to two questions we ask in prevention. Where can we intervene earlier, and what should we count to know whether it’s working?

A trauma kit is a downstream strategy. It helps after someone has already been shot. Gladwell also points to an opportunity to intervene further upstream when a disagreement starts to turn ugly. He highlights Becoming a Man, a Youth Guidance program that helps young men in Chicago pause during a conflict and consider what else might explain the other person’s actions before they respond. Early evaluations by the University of Chicago Crime Lab found fewer arrests for violent offenses while young men were in the program. (University of Chicago Crime Lab Study Finds Youth Program Reduces Violent Crime, Results Persist for Three Years, 2024)

Gladwell is at his best when he makes you reconsider a number you thought you understood. A community can record fewer firearm homicides even if just as many people are shot. Better trauma care is one way that can happen. A drop in deaths is good news. To learn whether fewer people are being shot, though, we have to count the people who survived, too.

At Indiana SADD, we encourage chapters to consider local data before they pick an activity, because local numbers can disclose patterns that state and even county-level data hide. A statewide report can show students that seat belt use deserves attention. A count in their own school parking lot can show whether drivers or passengers fasten their seat belts less often. That changes whom they talk to and what they ask them to do.

I’m glad that girl knew how to use the first kit. The question I take from Gladwell’s book is: What would it take for her to leave the next one unopened?

bottom of page